Confront, decode, or quietly start interviewing? What three executive coaches would do with that sentence
You are standing outside the conference room because the door never fully closed. Your boss is on the phone with his own boss, and the words that reach you are about you: "She's not quite ready." You miss the question. You miss whatever follows, because you step away, as any sensible person would. Back at your desk you have already played it over eleven times.
At 46 and a senior director, you have spent the last seven months handling VP-level responsibilities without anyone making the title official. That VP opening went up on the internal job board a fortnight ago. Somewhere, a decision was made that you lack what it takes, yet nobody has spelled out the standard that supposedly applies.
Option A. Confront
Back in the room, you sit down again. "I overheard part of your conversation. I'd rather hear the rest from you." The cost is that you have admitted to listening at a door, and he may turn defensive. A portion of managers actually value that sort of frankness. Others quietly file you as a problem as well as not ready. The upside is speed. By Friday you will know whether "not ready" is a sentence with a real definition behind it or a reflex that happens to carry a title.
Option B. Decode
Rather than dwelling on the call, you set it aside completely. Instead, you pose the question you ought to have asked seven months back: "What would I need to demonstrate for you to see me as the clear pick for the VP role?" After that, you jot down his reply, mail it to him so it's in writing, and start checking off each item. Expect it to take time, and expect the goalposts to move now and then. What you gain is a written record. If the requirements multiply each time you finish one, you will have that pattern in writing, which is worth more than anything you overheard.
Option C. Quietly start interviewing
You pick up two phone calls. The cost is energy you have little of, and a decision that may arrive sooner than you wanted. What you gain is bargaining power that is hard to secure by other means. Almost nothing exposes a vague "not quite ready" faster than a rival firm that already considers you ready.
Counsel from experienced leaders
Executives who have sat on both sides of that kind of conversation say "not quite ready" rarely describes a skill. Most of the time, the phrase reflects somebody's comfort level, and that somebody is usually the one saying it. According to a 2025 study by McKinsey and LeanIn, 93 women are promoted to manager for every 100 men, and 80% of women seek advancement compared with 86% of men, with the difference shrinking once support is evened out. Research by Tara Mohr, published through Harvard Business Review, suggests women often pass on roles chiefly because they read posted qualifications as strict requirements, not because their confidence is lacking. The word "ready" creates that same snare, only dressed up differently. You hear a rule. He meant a mood.
The same authors note that B accomplishes little without a set deadline, just as A accomplishes little without a sharp question behind it. The leaders who landed the role did both: asked for the definition in writing, with a date attached, and took one outside call that same week so the deadline carried real weight.
The verdict
It rests on whether he can explain it clearly. Requesting that definition this week is Option B, and it is what you should do first. Should his reply turn out concrete and carry a date, begin working toward it. If it stays vague, or a new item appears every month, Option C is already the answer, and your email will show why.
Your choice
What would you choose? Confront, decode, or quietly interview. Cast your vote below. Next week we will release the breakdown, together with the question most of you would have asked in the first place.