Why fixing the wrong one wastes a year, and six questions that tell them apart

Imagine a woman who, for the purposes of this chapter, we'll name Marisol. She is a composite drawn from several stories, so she is not a real member or client of ours. She is 47, a vice president of marketing in the Kansas City area, and for eleven months she has opened her résumé on Sunday nights and never sent it anywhere. She admits to friends that marketing has left her drained. Her husband has listened to stories about her new supervisor almost nightly since February, and he has a different theory about what's really going on.

That supervisor took his seat in February. He keeps moving her one-on-one meetings, forwards her projects to the CEO without naming her as the creator, and during team calls he wonders aloud whether she has "pressure-tested" work she already shipped. Prior to February, the role was something she truly looked forward to. Somewhere along the way she lost track of that.

What is at stake

If the trouble is the job but she treats it as a boss problem, she will sit tight, wait for him to leave, and still feel miserable once he's gone. If the trouble is the boss but she treats it as a job problem, she will walk away from a company she liked, land in a field she doesn't know, and carry him along in her head anyway. Either misreading tends to cost roughly a year.

SHORT The shift

The useful question isn't "do I like my boss?" Hardly anyone likes a terrible manager, and plenty of people dislike a good one. A more useful question is what would be different if the boss were no longer in the frame. Marisol runs this experiment on her commute along I-435. She pictures him moved up to a faraway corner office while someone competent but forgettable settles into the seat he left behind. The work is the same. The team is the same. She catches herself smiling. That reaction matters. It is the answer.

Why this reaches past Marisol

A 2025 TalentLMS survey of 1,000 employees found that 54% reported "quiet cracking," a slow erosion of motivation that doesn't look like resignation until it suddenly does. A bad manager is among the quickest ways to get there, and the damage is easy to misfile as "I'm finished with this career." The career is usually still intact. What's sitting in that chair is where the trouble lies.

SHORT Six questions to ask

First. Suppose your manager walked out tomorrow and everything else stayed the same, would you want to remain? A quick yes points to the boss.

Second. Were you happy in this position before this particular leader came along? When that's the case, the manager is the obstacle.

Third. Have three consecutive supervisors left you unable to get along with them? Next, examine the role itself, or the kind of role it is, with a more critical eye.

Fourth. Does the unease from Liberty or Lenexa stem from sessions with a particular person, or does it settle over every Monday no matter who is in charge? When the unease centers on a single person, the source is that person. Dread tied to the whole week is about the role.

Fifth. Even on difficult days, does the work still pull you in? When it does, the role itself isn't the issue.

Sixth. When you imagine your next position, is it the same kind of work under a different boss, or different work altogether? Trust the image that comes to mind.

Next steps based on what you found

If four or more point to the boss, the fix is a conversation or an internal transfer, not a career overhaul. Begin inside the relationship: "I'd like to understand how you want to work with me. Try saying something like, "Here's what I need from you to do my best work," and then agree on a checkpoint roughly ninety days later. If things stay the same, take concrete examples, rather than general frustration, to his supervisor or to HR. When your answers point to the job itself, quit faulting the person who showed up in February. He isn't worth a lost year.

On Sunday night, Marisol still has her résumé open on her screen. This week, for the first time, she has a clear sense of who it's really for.

Sources: