The three things they're judging, and none of them is your wardrobe

People sense executive presence through feedback they never had to be taught to notice. You hear you need more of it, no one can tell you what it looks like, and suddenly you're second-guessing your blazers. Pause there. The people evaluating it are weighing three things: whether they can trust you with a decision, whether you're listened to when you talk, and whether you hold your composure when things go sideways. Your wardrobe isn't on that list. The fuzziness isn't a coincidence either. Studies of the likability penalty keep finding that an identical ask reads as confident when a man makes it and as pushy when a woman does, and because "presence" is so vague, it's an easy spot for that bias to go unnoticed in Kansas City offices and beyond.

The scorecard

Think back over the last thirty days and answer with a plain yes or no. Score only what really happened, not what you would have done in an ideal world.

1. Lead with the bottom line when you propose something, then explain why afterward.

2. You pushed back on someone senior, out loud, in a meeting.

3. Could you name your team's mission in a single line that someone from outside the company would immediately understand?

4. Whenever a problem surfaces, colleagues in Kansas City and across the metro route it to you first, before anyone else.

5. In a meeting, you allow silence to linger rather than scrambling to cover it.

6. You said "I don't know, and I'll have an answer by Thursday," and then delivered it.

7. The notes you send to senior executives run briefer than the ones they send back to you.

8. When a senior colleague asked something you couldn't do, you declined and explained why in one tight sentence.

9. You appeared visibly calm in a room that wasn't.

Step ten. At a later meeting, a colleague echoed back a line you had said earlier.

Reading your score

Scores of eight through ten: well established. People in the room already see you as a person who decides things. If you're still getting the feedback, ask who is giving it and what they actually mean, because it may not be about you at all.

Scores of four through seven: beginning to emerge. Good instincts are already yours, and a portion of that signal is coming through. What's missing is mostly speed and economy: the recommendation up front, the tighter email, the pause you leave alone while the room catches up.

Scores of zero through three: capable, though reserved. You're delivering the work and leaving others to form their own view of its worth. That isn't a character flaw. Many of us were taught to lay out our reasoning before we'd earned the conclusion, and that was good advice for school, not for a boardroom.

Your following step

At eight to ten, whenever someone raises "presence," ask them, "What exactly would you like to see me do differently in our next meeting?" and jot down what they say. If nobody can give you an answer, the gap lies in the feedback, not in you.

A score of four to seven calls for a month in which every update you give opens with the decision you're after, stated in the first sentence. Change nothing else. Notice how the room responds.

At zero to three, try this at your next Overland Park or Olathe meeting: raise one brief disagreement with the most senior person present, then hold your tongue. Say something as simple as "I see it differently, and here's my reasoning," and then give them room to answer. The quiet pause that follows is where your presence lives.

Tally how many times you said yes, and share this with the woman in your Shawnee or Blue Springs circle who was told she lacks presence but never given a definition of it.

Sources: