Glass cliff or breakthrough: four questions that tell you which one you're looking at

On a Sunday evening, the board chair's call comes through to your phone. The division has lost money for six straight quarters, the previous two leaders were women, and both were gone within eighteen months. The job is yours if you want it: a larger title, a $90,000 pay bump, a place on the executive committee, and a mandate that, read closely, amounts to "repair what two people before you could not, with the same budget and the same board." You are 53. Five years of preparation have readied you for a position of this scale, and the timing of the offer makes its logic plain to you. The chair is waiting on your reply, which must arrive by Friday.

Whether you have the ability is not the central issue. What matters is whether this opportunity is a dead end or a turning point, and viewed from outside, the two are nearly indistinguishable.

Option A. Accept it as presented

Anyone can see the hazards right away. Should the division resist recovery, you will be added to a roster of failed leaders, and rosters are what stick in people's minds. Boards rarely pause to examine why three consecutive presidents fell short. Instead, they start searching for the next candidate, who tends to arrive with a bigger budget and greater latitude to make moves. Russell Reynolds found, across a small sample (so treat it as a warning sign rather than proof), that women CEOs averaged 5.2 years in the job compared with 8.1 years for men. Brief runways are a pattern, not a coincidence.

Option B. Turn it down

Looking closely, the drawbacks here are equally obvious. Positions of this scale do not open up every year, and "she passed on it" is a story that gets around Kansas City's business circles quickly. You keep your record spotless, but you may also be giving up your best shot at proving you can run something that loses money. At times, a dead end is nothing more than a dead end. Other times it is the difficult assignment nobody else wanted, and whoever steps into it collects the credit when it works.

Option C. Accept on your own terms

You agree, but with conditions, and you put them in writing before signing. A defined runway, a named board sponsor, a budget line that did not exist for your predecessors, and a success measure at eighteen months that goes beyond "profitable." The risk is that you may hear no. Yet a no to reasonable conditions is one of the most useful answers you will get all year, because it shows that they wanted a familiar name on the door, not a real turnaround.

Counsel from seasoned leaders

Executives who accepted a role like this in places such as Overland Park or Lee's Summit and then succeeded usually begin with four questions.

Initially. What were the reasons the previous two departed, as they themselves described them and not as the chair framed them? Call them. They will tell you.

Next. What has changed since then? If the reply comes back that the problem was you, treat that as flattery rather than a strategy.

Later. Which board member has a real stake in this result alongside you? When no one can name that individual, no one will defend you once the first quarter comes in short.

Finally. In a document, what would success look like after eighteen months? Without that document on paper, your performance cannot be measured fairly, yet you will be measured regardless.

The verdict

All of it depends on the first question. If the two predecessors were effectively set up to fail and only the title has been swapped out, push back, or renegotiate until something concrete changes. If something real has changed, accept, on paper and with a sponsor in place. Breakthroughs tend to look like cliffs that come with a budget attached.

Your vote

Which would you select? You can take it, turn it down, or take it with conditions attached. Vote below. Next week, we will release the findings alongside the question that most of you said you would raise first.

Sources: