A look back at what she was thinking, and what finally changed

Let's call her Megan. She is a composite, not a real member or client, but plenty of Kansas City women in leadership will recognize her. She is 51, the only woman on a nine-person executive team, and she is studying the promotion slate for the second time tonight. Gail has only just understood, sitting at the table with her own name on the screen above, that she is about to refuse.

For six years she has been the lone woman holding her seat. Kansas City's boardrooms have long rewarded women who stood apart from the rest, and Gail's own stand-out status came from hearing male colleagues call her "not like the others," a remark she privately enjoyed. The candidate is 38, sharp, and stronger with the numbers than Gail was at that age. The candidate and Gail are pulling from one budget, both need the CEO's calendar, and both are eyeing the same eventual chair.

Building a case against her would not take much effort. "Not ready," "give it another year," "strong but divisive": Gail has been on the receiving end of every one of these. This evening those are the words coming out of her own mouth.

Option A: Choose "not yet" and stand by it

She informs the committee in Overland Park that the candidate should wait another year. The price is that the candidate waits, figures out who did not speak up for her, and eventually walks out the door. Gail holds on to her seat and her status as the exception, yet the price is a pipeline that contains exactly one person.

Option B: Back her publicly and make room for the chair

"She's ready, and I'll stand behind her," Gail says, and she spends the following year clearing paths for her across the Kansas City metro. Giving up her position as the only woman at the top costs Gail something real, even if nobody in the room will name it. Her budget may shrink. Her CEO now has a second woman to weigh against her. In return, she gains a colleague instead of a reflection, and a track record of building something that outlasts her.

Option C: Stay quiet and leave it to the men

She opts out of voting. When the men decide by default, the patterns in the numbers end up deciding for them. A 2025 McKinsey and LeanIn report found that 31% of entry-level women have a sponsor versus 45% of men, and that for every 100 men promoted to manager, only 93 women are. Silence is a vote for the default.

What experienced executives say

Women in Independence, Lee's Summit, Blue Springs and Liberty who have spent years as the only one will see themselves in Gail immediately, and most will confess to a version of her story. In their telling, the impulse is rarely cruelty. It is scarcity. Because the exception was handed out as a reward, it feels like one, and women who receive it start protecting it long before they notice they're doing it. Those who have moved beyond it describe the exception seat as a quota of one, and holding onto it ends up doing the company's bidding by keeping the number small. Per that same McKinsey report, just 54% of companies put women's advancement near the top of their priorities. If Gail does not sponsor this candidate, odds are nobody else will.

The verdict

In the composite case, Gail picks Option A in year three and then watches that director walk out the door. By year six she goes with Option B, throwing her weight behind the woman on tonight's slate. Her character did not change in the meantime. It was the math. A pipeline built around one person falls apart the moment that person steps away, and Gail was always going to step away one day.

Whether this lesson applies to you depends on whether you believe there is room for more than one chair in the room. After enough years of being the only one, a person can lose track of the fact that it's not supposed to be that way. It is worth checking.

Ballot paper

If you had been in her chair the first time, which would you have picked, honestly: A, B or C? Write to the chapter with your letter, and next month we will share what readers said. If you have been on the other side of a Gail, we would also like to hear your story.

Sources: