"Ready" is a feeling in your boss's head. Here's how to put it there.
Most advice tells you to get ready before you raise your hand. Develop the skills the next position demands, enroll in the course, fill the holes in your background, and once you can truthfully say you're qualified, speak up. Earn it, then request it. Most of us were taught this way, and there's real integrity in it.
Yet "ready" isn't an objective measure of you. It's an image forming in your manager's mind, and the promotion tends to land with whoever already shows up in that image, whether or not they're the most qualified.
1. Readiness gets judged by resemblance, not by a checklist
When a leadership team talks about who could move up, almost nobody opens a competency spreadsheet. They picture the person doing the job. Could they picture her running the all-hands in Overland Park, calming a furious client, or presenting to the board? If so, she's ready. If not, she needs "a bit more seasoning," which says more about their imagination than about her record. According to McKinsey and LeanIn's Women in the Workplace 2025 study, women in leadership are twice as often taken for a junior employee. When a room assumes you are junior, it has a hard time imagining you in a senior seat.
2. People interpret an identical checklist in very different ways.
Tara Mohr's survey, published in Harvard Business Review, showed that women often skip roles they feel underqualified for largely because they treat the posted requirements as hard rules. Men often see that same list as a set of aspirations they can grow into. So she waits until she meets every line, while the man who meets six of ten applies, gets pictured in the role, and gets it. At the very moment she decided she wasn't ready, she was actually the more qualified candidate.
3. The gap in ambition is not really what it seems.
The same McKinsey and LeanIn research shows 80% of women seek a promotion, against 86% of men, and that the difference disappears once support is distributed equally. Women aren't less ambitious. Women are simply given fewer opportunities to be observed performing the next role before it becomes officially theirs, and observation is what forms the mental image.
Where the old advice still holds up
Skill still counts for a great deal. A promotion into a role you can't yet handle is a glass cliff with a better announcement. Russell Reynolds data indicates women CEOs stay in post for an average of 5.2 years, compared with 8.1 years for men. The sample is modest, yet it is revealing, and part of the reason is that women are frequently positioned to fail. So prepare. Do not wait until your preparation feels complete before making yourself visible.
A new method
Get into the mental picture of the role while it is still open, not after. In Kansas City, lead the meeting your manager typically runs whenever she's out, for example at the Overland Park or Lenexa office. Once a quarter, bring something that matters to her own manager and walk them through it. Then state plainly what you are after: "When the VP position opens, I want to be considered for it. What evidence would you want to see from me before then?" Their reply becomes your genuine roadmap, and it tends to be far leaner than the list you would have invented alone. Each month, deliver one visible piece of it before the very people who will be deciding when the name comes up.
When your leaders discuss the next VP, is your name a clear picture or just a maybe?