Why decisiveness reads as "difficult" on you, and the three moves that change the read
For twenty years the coaching has been steady. If a decisive move makes you look "difficult," soften it. Smile more. Begin by saying "I could be mistaken, though." Then express gratitude for everyone's patience. Surround the hard call with enough warmth that no one registers that you made it. Mentors in this field call it reading the room, and they pass it along with sincere intentions.
A gentler delivery leaves the cost exactly where it was. It accepts the idea that your authority needs an apology, and it costs you the clarity that made the decision right to begin with.
Single. Because the cost follows the speaker rather than the wording, a softer tone won't lower what you pay.
Studies of the likability penalty have repeatedly found that the same request sounds assertive coming from a man and demanding coming from a woman. Identical is the important word. The words were the same. People responded differently depending on the speaker's identity. Tweaking how you deliver a message targets a factor the evidence shows is irrelevant, while the factor that truly matters goes untouched.
Two. Polite requests have been tested widely already and haven't solved it.
Bargaining is more common than many assume: according to Kray, Kennedy, and Lee at Berkeley Haas in 2023, 54% of women haggled over their latest offer, while only 44% of men did, and still the women walked away with less money. Women are not failing to ask. Women do make requests, frequently with great tact, and still bear the cost. If politeness fixed the read, that gap would have closed years ago in Kansas City and across the metro. Plenty of Kansas City professionals who negotiate offers at the region's large employers, from health systems like Saint Luke's and the University of Kansas Health System to firms like Burns & McDonnell, have seen the same pattern.
Three. Hedging undermines your next decision too.
Each "I could be mistaken" remains in the written record. At the next tough decision, colleagues recall your qualifiers and interpret your new call through that lens. The man who made the same call without the cushion is now "decisive." You are now "unsure." You have paid the penalty twice: once for being a woman, and once for the padding you added to avoid being seen as one.
Where conventional wisdom still applies
Warmth is a real asset, and many of the women leading organizations across the metro have it in abundance. The error lies in treating warmth as a markdown on authority rather than as a distinct asset in its own right. Be kind. Be clear. Do not trade one for the other.
The better approach
Base the choice on an agreed benchmark. "Our rule is that we don't ship without the security review, and this one hasn't had it." Once that is said, the room stops debating you, even in a Lenexa or Shawnee office. They are contesting the standard, and standards are never called difficult.
Write it down before you sit down together. When a decision is circulated as a written memo that lays out its rationale, it is received as procedure. That identical decision, announced in person, is heard as a matter of temperament. Send the memo, then hold the meeting to discuss it, so the paper is the part that was firm. Local networks such as WIRED KC and the Women Construction Owners and Executives KC Chapter are good places to test how this works in practice with peers who have made similar calls.
State the cost aloud before anyone else raises it. "This will be unpopular with the vendor, and I'm making the call anyway because of our audit exposure." You have named the "difficult" before it can be used against you, and attached it to a reason. Stated reasoning is what people tend to credit to assertive men by default. Give yours out loud.
In Independence or Liberty, which decision are you watering down right now that you'd state plainly if you were certain the room would read it as leadership?