How to price what you'd give up, what you'd get back, and the number that sets you free
Consider Lorraine, who is a composite figure and not an actual member or client of ours. She is 54, the chief financial officer of a division, and she has just done the thing finance professionals are trained to do but often avoid. She has placed a price tag on her own handcuffs.
Across the top of her legal pad, the sum comes to $410,000. That sum is made up of her unvested equity, a retention bonus payable in nineteen months, and deferred compensation that she would lose if she quit. Although the figures are hypothetical, they feel entirely real to her. Beneath them she has jotted down something she has never said aloud: four years of being passed over for the group CFO role, with an outside candidate brought in each time.
What is at risk for her
Staying means she receives the $410,000 while also holding onto her title, the team she assembled, and her Tuesday lunches with the general counsel. She also keeps a pattern. Within this organization, the division CFO post is the role leaders give to people they rely on but do not intend to advance. Over the years she has seen two men pass through that position on their way to bigger roles. Neither stayed four years.
Should she walk away, the money she has built up gets left behind. Nineteen months of pay, along with the equity, would simply vanish. When a recruiter reached out about a CFO role at a publicly traded company, they stated plainly that the base salary would be in the same range. Less clear was everything else.
SHORT Pivot
Lorraine checks the math again, just as she would for any member of her own team. The $410,000 is not really a single lump sum. If you divide the total across the nineteen months she would need to stay, it comes to about $21,500 per month before taxes. That amount represents what every month of waiting actually costs her. She then poses a question she has never considered before: what is a single month of her career worth to her at age 54? Not to the company, but to her. The question that follows changes everything: who else might be willing to pay that cost?
Companies buy out golden handcuffs regularly. That is exactly why sign-on bonuses and make-whole equity grants have become standard tools. Her $410,000 is not a wall. It is an opening offer.
Why this goes beyond Lorraine
According to the 2025 Women in the Workplace report from McKinsey and LeanIn, only 54% of companies treat women's advancement as a high priority. Most of the remaining firms still set aside funds to keep people on staff. A retention bonus is often what a company offers in place of a plan, and a generous bonus does not make up for the absence of one.
Three takeaways worth keeping
First. Price your handcuffs honestly. Add up everything you would give up by departing, and then divide that sum by the number of months you would have to stay to receive it. The resulting monthly figure shows what each month of waiting truly costs, and that figure is far more modest than the large lump sum suggests.
Second. Ask the market to cover it. "My unvested compensation is roughly X. What would it take to make me whole?" Bring this up with a recruiter during the first conversation rather than at the end. Credible employers budget a specific line for this purpose. Employers who are less serious will make that clear by quickly moving on to another topic.
Third. Fix your lowest acceptable offer before the pressure builds in Overland Park or Olathe. Note the amount that would persuade you to move and the deadline after which no amount will. With those in hand, you bargain from a concrete number instead of a gut reaction.
Lorraine's legal pad now holds three numbers. The first is what it will cost her to remain. The second is what another company might be willing to offer. The third is the sum she has concluded she is owed.