What a decade of "lean in" got wrong, and what actually moves women up

When Kansas City women received their most recent job offer, 54 percent of them pushed for a higher figure. Among men, 44 percent took that same step. Still, the women came away earning less. The research behind this, carried out by Kray, Kennedy and Lee at Berkeley Haas in 2023 and reported by Fortune, overturns a decade of advice about careers in one stroke.

Throughout the years of the "lean in" movement, a tidy story took hold. Women earn less and climb more slowly because they fail to ask. Address the asking through confidence workshops, negotiation seminars and a firm reminder to value yourself, the reasoning went, and the gap would narrow. For employers this was a convenient story, since every fix it offered fell on the woman herself. The Berkeley research flips that logic. In reality, women request raises more often than men do, yet they still come up short.

Source of the figure

The work was done at the Haas School of Business at UC Berkeley, led by Laura Kray with Jessica Kennedy and Margaret Lee, and it examined how people negotiated after receiving recent job offers. The surprise was that women negotiated at a higher rate. What stands out more is that, even so, their earnings remained lower. A single study has limits. It does not prove women negotiate more skillfully or less, and it does not pin down every factor behind the difference. The finding strips away the most straightforward account of the gap. A gap cannot be blamed on a behavior that women are already performing more frequently.

Additional studies from other teams arrive at much the same conclusion. Research on the likability penalty has shown again and again that a request word for word is perceived as confident when a man delivers it but as pushy when a woman does. Taken together, the evidence suggests the problem is not that women don't ask. Women do ask, and the people across the table penalize them for it.

What it looks like on the ground

Imagine you are at the offer stage for a role you want, here in the Kansas City area. You have reviewed three postings that list pay ranges, you know where the midpoint sits, and you ask for it calmly, with clear reasons. A recruiter in the Kansas City metro tells a candidate she will "see what she can do," then comes back with an offer roughly two thousand dollars higher and calls it a stretch. A man interviewing for the same position asks for the top of the range and lands near it, and his offer is called "competitive." You negotiated, and so did he, yet the results differ. Nothing you said on that call could have changed the outcome, because the decision about what your request was worth had already been made before the conversation began.

What this means for someone in Kansas City or Overland Park

If you have ever been told you need more confidence, look closely at what that advice accomplished. The explanation locates the problem inside the individual, where correcting it asks nothing of the employer. Tulshyan and Burey made a similar argument about imposter syndrome in Harvard Business Review in 2021: the label turns a systemic problem into an individual one. Framing the issue as a confidence gap simply repackages that same shift in language. You do not need repairing. The workplace needs examining.

Next steps

Instead of focusing on your own worth, ask what the pay band for the role looks like. Try, "What is the posted range for this level, and where does this offer fall within it?" Posted ranges are now required in a growing number of states, so the question has a factual answer. Then ask the question that is hard to dismiss as a matter of personality: "What would it take to reach the midpoint?" You are negotiating based on the numbers, and the numbers do not make you look demanding.

Think back: when did you last push for a raise, and what did it cost you?

Sources: